OLDEST IN AMERICA Icons & villages Photo: DanTD · CC BY-SA 3.0
St. James General Store
St. James, NY · 🚂 ~0.4 mi from St. James LIRR
The oldest continuously operating general store in America, selling penny candy and stick pretzels since 1857. Suffolk County Parks runs it now, and it still smells exactly right.
Know something about St. James General Store we don't? Add a local tip. Run this spot? Claim your listing — free, forever.